In 1939 Wendell Johnson set up ‘The Monster Study', which engaged placing twenty-two orphan children into two experimental teams, the ‘stutterers' and the ‘non-stutterers'. Though it is necessary to note that just half of the children put into the ‘stuttering' group actually a new stuttering trouble. The non-stuttering group received positive speech therapy, praising how very well and fluent they chatted, while the various other group received negative talk therapy, rebuked for every single imperfection and told these were stutterers. Right at the end of the experiment the children who have before had had simply no problems with their very own speech at this point did, and 3 in the 5 kids who already had stutters were considerably worse. The reasons that this test is considered unethical will be due to various reasons. Firstly as orphan children had been chosen in this study, not only did they may have no one to stand up for them, but they also was missing the right to take away. This was largely due to the fact that these were completely unaware of the purpose, and also the true purpose of the experiment. This means that the 22 children were placed in this research against all their will and were basically ordered to go with it, and since they did not really understand what they were a part of got no reason to question it or ask for the analysis to be halted. Also your children in the stuttering group were effectively mentally harmed for a very long time, as when ever Johnson learned his hypothesis-that fluency in speech is due to development not trait, was correct, then he realised it was too late to reverse this. Therefore the kids had to live with their presentation impediments. Today this would be seen as an complete breach of kids rights set up in 1989. For example 1 concept of children's rights is usually ‘A child has the right to be protected against significant harm' and since this includes the two mental and emotional injury, this Monster Study could evidently always be deemed dishonest. However it is necessary to point out that...

Tags:

Essay in Awakening: the Role Model

eggless hotcakes Essay